Most arguments about self-driving cars are arguments from a 2018 article. Here's where today's commercial fleets actually stand on the eight claims that come up at every dinner table.
Mostly True
“Self-driving cars are way safer than human drivers.”
Across 56.7M rider-only miles, Waymo logged 90% fewer serious-injury crashes and 92% fewer pedestrian-injury crashes than the human baseline for the same cities. The catch: most of those miles are in mild-weather urban grids — not snowy interstates.
sourceWaymo / Swiss Re peer-reviewed safety study, 2024
Partly True
“These things constantly block traffic and clog intersections.”
Cruise was a real menace before GM shut it down — pile-ups in San Francisco intersections happened weekly. Waymo's modern fleet gets stuck about 1 in every 4,000 trips and remote operators usually free it inside two minutes. It still happens; the rate is just much lower than the headlines suggest.
sourceSFMTA incident logs, 2023–2025
True
“They're rolling cameras that record everything around them.”
Every robotaxi continuously logs LiDAR sweeps, 360° camera feeds, and audio inside the cabin. Footage is retained ~30 days by default. Police in SF, LA, and Phoenix have already subpoenaed it for unrelated criminal cases — sometimes successfully.
sourceBloomberg, 2024 reporting on AV subpoenas
False
“Robotaxis will replace human drivers in five years.”
There are roughly 4,500 driverless cars operating in the US today against ~280 million registered passenger vehicles. Even at Waymo's current 2x-per-year ride growth, that's a 15-to-25 year glide path — and it skips the trucking and rural slices entirely.
sourceFHWA registration data + Waymo growth curve
False
“Tesla FSD is the same thing as a Waymo.”
Waymo, Zoox, and Aurora all run multi-sensor stacks (LiDAR + radar + cameras) with no human required. Tesla FSD is camera-only Level 2+, which means a licensed driver has to be ready to take over at all times. The Cybercab pilot in Austin is Tesla's first true Level 4 deployment, and it's invite-only with a tiny fleet.
sourceSAE level definitions; Tesla FSD owner's manual
False
“If a robotaxi hits something, you're on the hook as the rider.”
Operators carry the liability. Waymo and Zoox are self-insured and settle property and injury claims directly with affected parties. Riders don't need supplemental coverage and can't be sued for the car's behavior — the same way you can't be sued for an Uber driver's lane change.
sourceWaymo terms of service; CA DMV operator requirements
False
“They only work in California and Phoenix.”
As of April 2026, commercial driverless rides are running in San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix, Austin, Atlanta, and Miami — six metros across five states. Dallas, Nashville, and DC are next on Waymo's 2026 expansion list.
sourceWaymo press releases; this dashboard's city tracker
Partly True
“They get confused by anything unusual on the road.”
Edge cases that were nightmares in 2020 — double-parked delivery trucks, weird left turns, jaywalkers — are now handled smoothly. What still trips them up: human hand signals from cops or flaggers, big-event crowds, and sustained snow or ice. The car's response is to stop and ask remote support, not to guess.
sourceCA DMV disengagement reports, 2024–2025